
Thompson Central Park New York
Best for travelers who want a modern, social Midtown stay with an on‑site spa, rooftop pool, and several casually stylish dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Thompson Central Park New York is a contemporary, social Midtown boutique-lifestyle hotel with a rooftop-level pool and exhale Spa; this guide is for travelers who want a modern, lively base near Carnegie Hall and Central Park. The St. Regis New York is a classic Fifth Avenue ultra-luxury hotel with butler service and heritage style; read on if you prefer old‑world luxury and Fifth Avenue addresses.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for travelers who want a modern, social Midtown stay with an on‑site spa, rooftop pool, and several casually stylish dining options.

Best for travelers seeking polished, heritage Fifth Avenue luxury with Butler Service and a traditional, formal hotel experience.
Thompson Central Park New York wins when you want a more contemporary, social hotel scene, on-site spa programming (exhale), an enclosed rooftop-level pool open year-round, and multiple casually approachable restaurants including Parker’s and Burger Joint.
The St. Regis New York wins when you want Fifth Avenue prestige, classic ultra‑luxury touches (including Butler Service in many room types), a quieter, more formal luxury environment, and a central Midtown address steps from Rockefeller Center and 5th Avenue shopping.
Bottom line: pick Thompson for modern social energy, wellness and a rooftop pool; pick The St. Regis for heritage Fifth Avenue luxury and traditional service. Both are strong Midtown choices depending on whether you prefer contemporary lifestyle amenities or Old‑World polish.
| Category | Thompson Central Park New York | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary boutique-lifestyle, social public spaces | Classic, formal Fifth Avenue ultra-luxury |
| Location (Midtown) | 119 West 56th Street — same block as Carnegie Hall; two blocks from Central Park | Two East 55th St — steps from 5th Avenue and minutes from Rockefeller Center |
| Size (guestrooms) | 587 or 613 rooms listed inconsistently across sources | 238 guestrooms |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in from 3:00 PM; check-out by 12:00 PM | Check-in begins 4:00 PM; check-out by 12:00 PM |
| Pools / signature amenity | Indoor enclosed rooftop-level pool kept around 75°F year-round, plus outdoor sundeck | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | exhale Spa (6,000+ sq ft) with treatments, saunas, classes and a $25 daily credit toward spa/fitness | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Parker’s (New American, live jazz), Burger Joint (casual), Indian Accent (fine dining) plus a bar/lounge | 2 restaurants and 1 bar/lounge (room service available during limited hours) |
| Accessible / family policy | All ages welcome; guests must be 18+ to check in | All ages welcome (property does not appear to be adults-only); check-in min age 21 reported in supplier listing |
| Notable service features | Upper Stories paid upgrade (private check-in, lounge, breakfast/snacks), valet parking only, pet-friendly | Butler Service included in many room types, concierge, valet parking (surcharge) |
| Nearby highlights | Carnegie Hall, Central Park, MoMA, Broadway theaters, Fifth Avenue | 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center, Radio City Music Hall, Central Park |
Thompson Central Park New York sits on West 56th Street on the same block as Carnegie Hall and a short walk from the southern edge of Central Park.
Choose Thompson if you want to be near Carnegie Hall and Central Park with easy neighborhood walking access.
The St. Regis New York is positioned on Fifth Avenue near East 55th Street, putting you close to Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping.
Choose The St. Regis for a Fifth Avenue address and immediate access to Midtown’s classic shopping and cultural landmarks.
Thompson markets roomy rooms (many over 300 sq ft), Upper Stories upgrades, and a mix of studios and suites.
Choose Thompson for contemporary rooms, a paid top-floor upgrade with lounge access, and family-friendly layouts.
The St. Regis offers classic luxury room types and many options that include Butler Service as noted in supplier room names.
Choose The St. Regis if you want formal service touches like Butler Service and a full suite lineup with classic room layouts.
Thompson Central Park New York offers three distinct on-site restaurants and an on-site bar/lounge with a range from casual to fine dining.
Choose Thompson for variety: casual late-night burgers, jazz-forward American dining, and an elevated Indian option under one roof.
The St. Regis lists two on-site restaurants and a bar/lounge and offers room service during limited hours.
Choose The St. Regis for a more formal dining experience associated with a traditional luxury hotel; specific restaurant concepts vary by season and booking source.
Thompson’s signature non-room amenity is its enclosed rooftop-level pool kept around 75°F year‑round with an outdoor sundeck.
Thompson is the clearer choice if an on-site year-round pool is a priority.
Supplier information does not publish an on-site pool for The St. Regis New York.
If a hotel pool is essential, Thompson’s rooftop pool is a documented advantage; St. Regis pool information is not published in the provided listing.
Thompson pairs exhale Spa programming with a fitness center and nightly live music in Parker’s.
Thompson is the pick for integrated wellness programming plus an on-site live-music nightlife component.
The St. Regis provides full-service hotel amenities, concierge, business and event spaces, and classic evening service, but the provided supplier listing does not detail an on-site spa brand comparable to exhale.
Choose St. Regis for formal service and event facilities; choose Thompson for a stronger documented spa and active evening programming.

Thompson Central Park New York — exhale Spa, fitness classes and a $25 daily credit for spa/fitness.

Thompson Central Park New York — enclosed rooftop-level pool open year-round (about 75°F).

The St. Regis New York — classic Fifth Avenue address and a heritage luxury experience with Butler Service.

The St. Regis New York — many room types explicitly list Butler Service and a range of named suites.
Thompson Central Park New York — it sits on the same block as Carnegie Hall and is about two blocks from the southern edge of Central Park.
Thompson Central Park New York has an indoor, enclosed rooftop-level pool kept around 75°F year-round. The St. Regis supplier listing does not publish pool details.
The St. Regis New York is the clearer choice for traditional, heritage luxury and Butler Service listed for many rooms and suites.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages, though some listings note minimum check-in ages (Thompson: 18; The St. Regis supplier lists min age 21 to check in).
Explore how Thompson Central Park New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·