
Thompson Central Park New York
Best for families and anyone who wants a lively Midtown address with an indoor rooftop-level pool and multiple on-site dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Thompson Central Park New York is a Midtown boutique-lifestyle hotel with family-friendly energy, a year-round enclosed rooftop-level pool, and three distinct restaurants—good for families, culture seekers, and travelers who want to be in the theater/Shopping district. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is an Upper East Side, Corinthia-branded luxury property near Central Park and the Met—aimed at travelers who prefer a quieter, refined museum-and-shopping base.
Updated · about 1.8 km apart

Best for families and anyone who wants a lively Midtown address with an indoor rooftop-level pool and multiple on-site dining options.

Best for travelers seeking a quieter, Upper East Side luxury stay within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
When Thompson Central Park New York wins: choose Thompson if you want a Midtown location close to Carnegie Hall, Broadway and Fifth Avenue shopping, easy family-friendly dining (Burger Joint), and the convenience of a year-round rooftop-level pool and on-site exhale Spa.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: pick The Surrey for a more restrained, Upper East Side luxury vibe, linen-and-pillowtop-focused rooms with Frette sheets, an intimate scale (about 100 rooms), and immediate access to the Met and Madison Avenue shopping.
Bottom line: both are luxury options in Manhattan but serve slightly different needs—Thompson is livelier and more family-oriented with a rooftop pool and multiple eateries; The Surrey is a quieter, classical luxury alternative for museum-goers and shoppers on the Upper East Side.
| Category | Thompson Central Park New York | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique-lifestyle, lively Midtown with multiple dining venues and live music programming | Upper East Side, classical Corinthia-branded luxury and a quieter residential feel |
| Location | 119 West 56th Street — same block as Carnegie Hall; southern edge of Central Park; Midtown/Theater District | 20 East 76th Street — Upper East Side, about a 5-minute walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size (rooms) | Reported roughly 587–613 rooms across sources (large for a Manhattan 'boutique') | 100 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-friendly (rooms >300 sq ft noted), 18+ to check in | All ages welcome; not adults-only (minimum check-in age not published in supplier listing) |
| Pools / signature water feature | Indoor, enclosed rooftop-level pool kept around 75°F year-round with outdoor sundeck | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues: Parker's (New American, live jazz), Burger Joint (casual), Indian Accent (fine-dining) | One signature on-site restaurant (Casa Tua — Italian) with 24-hour room service and a bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | exhale Spa (about 6,000 sq ft) with massages, facials, saunas, fitness classes and Peloton-equipped gym | Full-service spa with treatment rooms and reservations required for services |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, live-jazz restaurant program at Parker's, multiple distinct dining options | Refined Upper East Side service, proximity to the Met and Madison Ave luxury shopping; Frette sheets and pillowtop beds |
| Parking & transport notes | Valet parking only; walking distance to major Midtown attractions and subway links | Valet parking (surcharge) and limo/town car service available; close to Central Park and museum corridor |
| Pet policy highlights | Pet-friendly with food/water bowls and optional pet services (fees vary by listing) | Pet fee listed (USD 275 per pet, per stay) with service animals exempt |
Thompson Central Park sits on West 56th Street on the same block as Carnegie Hall and steps from Central Park South.
Choose Thompson for a central Midtown base if you want immediate access to theaters, shops and Midtown attractions.
The Surrey is on East 76th Street, an Upper East Side address a few blocks from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Pick The Surrey when you want a calm, museum-and-shopping-focused Upper East Side location.
Thompson’s rooms and suites include several categories (Deluxe, Park View, Studio Suite) and larger room sizes noted for families.
Thompson works well for families or guests who want extra space and an option to upgrade to an 'Upper Stories' experience.
The Surrey offers a compact, refined set of rooms and suites focused on traditional luxury touches.
The Surrey suits travelers who prioritize classical room finishes and a quieter room experience near the Met.
Thompson offers three distinct on-site venues to cover casual to fine dining.
If variety and on-site dining options matter, Thompson’s three concepts cover everything from quick burgers to fine dining.
The Surrey centers on a single signature Italian restaurant and a quieter dining scene.
The Surrey is a good fit if you want refined, quieter in-house dining and service rather than multiple casual options.
Thompson has an indoor, enclosed rooftop-level pool that operates year-round.
Thompson’s rooftop-level pool is a rare year-round Manhattan pool option, appealing to families and water-minded guests.
The supplier listing for The Surrey does not publish a pool on-site.
The Surrey’s materials emphasize classical luxury and location; a pool is not published in the supplier listing.
Thompson pairs an on-site exhale Spa and fitness offerings with an active evening dining and live-music program.
Thompson is the pick for guests who want spa treatments plus a livelier evening scene with live music.
The Surrey emphasizes refined on-site service and a full-service spa experience in a quieter neighborhood setting.
Choose The Surrey for a quieter wellness-focused stay and easy access to the museum corridor and Madison Avenue.

Thompson Central Park New York — family-friendly rooms, casual Burger Joint, and an indoor rooftop-level pool.

The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel — walkable to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Madison Avenue boutiques.

Thompson Central Park New York — three distinct restaurants covering casual to fine dining and live music at Parker’s.

The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel — a classical luxury address on the Upper East Side with refined in-room bedding and service.
The Surrey is a short walk (about 5 minutes) to the Metropolitan Museum of Art; Thompson is farther south in Midtown.
Thompson Central Park New York has an indoor, enclosed rooftop-level pool kept around 75°F year-round. The Surrey’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
No. Thompson Central Park New York is family-friendly and The Surrey is not adults-only.
Thompson Central Park New York’s Midtown location is closer to Broadway theaters, late-night dining and a livelier evening scene.
Explore how Thompson Central Park New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·